Oh Please SOMEONE Talk To These Children

03.21.10

We had a lovely weekend. The kids and I. Alexander had Little League Baseball games on both Saturday and Sunday, Jane had a sleepover Saturday night, and both kids got to play with their friends who are moving back to Australia.

Today I wanted to take them up and down Auto Row so they could sit in the backseat of a few cars. Even if I like a car, the kids need to be comfortable in the back seat. We went to Subaru and they went nuts for the Outback. I can’t go for a car that doesn’t have heat or air vents in the back seats. They’re going to be miserable back there.

I digress.

After we came back from car shopping, but before heading off to my mom’s house for dinner, the kids retreated for a little quiet time. I went into my office to look at a few car options online, and Alexander tapped me on the shoulder and said, “Can I read this book?” “Sure”, I said without so much as turning my head.

A few moments later I heard a gasp from the playroom followed by Alexander muttering eew gross. The book he’d asked to read? It’s called “Where Did I Come From”, and I remember buying it for my kids, because it was the book my mother bought me. It includes pictures an awful lot like this.

Where Did I Come From

I took a deep breath and asked my son if he wanted to talk about the book. He muttered something about Dad already told me this. I asked him if there were any new bits of information? He muttered again about how Dad told him everything so I told him that I’d be happy to talk to him, but if he wanted to wait a day he could talk to Dad tomorrow or even Grandpa today.

He shook his head, and I asked him if he’d like to continue reading the book alone. My boy is not a talker, and today I loved him a little more for that.

Everyone goes about their business, the kids play on the street, and I get us ready to go to my Mom’s for dinner. Dinner is great, we head back home and there is hideous traffic on the 405 Sepulveda Pass and it appeared that Sepulveda Blvd was a mess too. I turned on news radio (something I never do with kids in the car) and we got to hear about Health-care Reform while waiting for a traffic report.

“Mom, what’s an abortion?” Jane asked me.

Traffic, traffic everywhere.There is no escaping this conversation. I take a deep breath and I explain that the abortion bill will never affect her but that it is very very bad.

I tell my daughter how people who can’t afford health care will get health care from the government, but that it will not cover the cost of an abortion. I tell her this is a mistake, because women who cannot get abortions will find other ways, and illegal abortions may be less expensive but they will also be dangerous and girls will die. Equally awful is forcing a young woman to be a mother when she is not ready.

I told both kids that they must use birth control, they will have sex, but they must not do it without birth control because there are diseases and babies they aren’t ready for. I said, “You are not to have unprotected sex until after you are married.” I look to my son to ask what he thinks, he is in the fetal position asleep. Jane wants to know who gets abortions. Clearly this question is relevant since I’ve basically told my children they will be having premarital sex, just not without a condom.

Girls a lot like you. “The health care bill won’t ever apply to you”, I tell her, “you and your friends, you have insurance, and you have parents who will help you no matter what.” I can’t give my eleven year old daughter permission to have an abortion, but she has to know I’m here.

I want to tell her that abortions are terrible and that babies die. I want to explain that it’s an agonizing decision for most women, because it does involve ending another life. I want her to know that I think it’s wrong. I don’t tell her these things. I bite my tongue.

I need my daughter to trust me. This conversation, this bumper to bumper traffic at eight on a Saturday night, may be our lifeline one day. Our casual conversations are loaded. My daughter is a bright girl, and she remembers minutia. She senses the subtexts of conversations.What if? Not for her, but for one of her friends? What if there’s a need and my daughter doesn’t trust me?

I thrust my eleven year old daughter headlong into the Women’s Liberation movement. I did it all while driving a station wagon.

  • http://wwwjackbenimble.blogspot.com/ Jack

    I”ll trade you my “Dad what is prostate cancer” conversation with abortion. Not to say that it is not difficult, but it is a bit more vague and nebulous right now.

  • http://rootsandflowers.blogspot.com/ Annica

    Well done, Mama!
    When will you be bringing your station wagon through my neighborhood? I’ll have a gaggle of tweens & teens out on the curb waiting for you! Could be a new thing for you – maybe get one of those magnetic signs to slap on the side of the wagon?

  • http://www.peanutbutterandpickles.blogspot.com Marvin

    Congratulations on passing another parental milestone while stuck in traffic! Those are tough conversations to have, but kids appreciate honesty. It’s best to give too much information than not enough.

    I have yet to meet a woman who’s had an abortion who didn’t regret it. And I’ve met many. So many abortions could be prevented by just exercising better judgment in the first place.

    And you obliquely addressed the whole problem with the health care bill – everyone pays, but most won’t ever use its services. That’s pretty unethical.

    • http://www.budgetconfessions.blogspot.com Cate

      I know many women who have had abortions and don’t regret it, and I’ve met many.

  • http://www.MarVistaMom.com Sarah Auerswald

    You don’t need anyone else to talk to your kids — you’re doing a great job, especially for a closet feminist.

  • Mikalan

    We had a similar conversation at the dinner table with our 4 children during the election. It was challenging. What I found interesting was each of our kids took a different stance on abortion. I will add that one of those kids was a boy. Some people might see it as strange that we would discuss this with our kids, let alone at the dinner table. However, this is where we share our day, and the topic came up, and I didnt want to create any discomfort over it. I also found it hard to keep my opinnion out of it, and let them decide for themselves how they felt. Even though some of what they decided didnt mesh with my beliefs I felt a little victorious because we had discussed it, and they had made decisions on their own, and they felt confident enough to do it, and to speak their mind regarding what they decided. As a mom, that is exactly what I want for my kids. Good job Jessica.

  • http://www.secretinnerlife.com subWOW

    Decided to unlurk myself (again) to give you a pat on the back. That’s as good as a conversation wrt. this subject as I could ever imagine, esp. considering the audience. Great job! And kudos to biting your tongue. Sometimes biting our tongue is the hardest part.

  • JJ McFee

    Marvin – I have not, do not, and will not ever regret my decision to have an abortion. Now you’ve met one :)

  • http://formerlyaprildawn.blogspot.com April

    You handled it great and I don’t think Jane will need anyone else to talk to, but I would recommend telling her that it’s okay to talk to another trusted female adult if she needs to. Sylvia and I have come up with 3 adult female allies that she can go to if she’s ever afraid to talk to me. (Hers are her therapist, my sister, and my mother. I’m good with that.)
    I think my own parents were just grateful that when I was 12, I had the opportunity to tour Planned Parenthood!

  • http://www.mybottlesup.com nic @mybottlesup

    Betty Friedan is proud, as am I.

  • Gaston Hidalgo

    My daughter will have a baby in October, apparently for my birthday, I get this gift; I digress like you; she is 19, I never, nor his mother told her anything whatsoever about abortion; it did not even feature in her conversations the possibility of it, we just asked “How do you feel about it?” She said, well, “how do you make that barley drink you use to give me when I was a baby and a toddler”…I guess the fact that she knows we are with her all the way, whatever happens in her life has something to do with her absolute and unsaid full responsibility taken…My guess is that you do not have to worry about words or arguments related to the subject, your firm hand and love for her will do what is necessary…Much love and success to you

  • http://www.tempestbeauty.com Mandy

    I have tears in my eyes right now. I found you through a link on Twitter and will retweet. I don’t have a daughter, but if I ever do, I hope I handle a question like this one with as much skill and grace.

    Thank you for sharing this, and thank you for teaching your daughter something so important. This was just wonderful.

  • Jeanniedee

    My 7 yr old is just about to finish up a class geared to her age about her body, sex, families, and safety. Abortion is not covered, but just about everything else is. I hope I handle the question as well as you did!

  • http://www.adventuresinbabywearing.com Adventures In Babywearing

    This really hits a tender spot in my heart today, and is relieving, really. I admire how you converse with your children, I know they mean the world to you, and that you want the best for them, and that you’re there for them no matter what. I long for this. Many of us longed for that when we were their age, too.

    Steph

  • Gretchen

    Wow, great job. Nothing, is more important than communication, but understading that they may not tell you everything is so important too. Communicating love is somethimes easier than communicating words.

  • @johnincolorado

    “I want to tell her that abortions are terrible and that babies die. I want to explain that it’s an agonizing decision for most women, because it does involve ending another life. I want her to know that I think it’s wrong. I don’t tell her these things. I bite my tongue.”

    I feel slow here but I don’t understand why you didn’t say these things. It seems clear to the other people leaving comments and they get what you are saying. I don’t. Can you clarify for me? Might help me out.

    • http://JessicaGottlieb.com Jessica Gottlieb

      Because if my daughter ever finds herself pregnant and unmarried I don’t want her afraid to talk to me.

      That is the one and only reason. I love her more than I’ll ever love anyone, and I need her to always trust me.

  • Mikalan

    I can’t speak for Jessica, or anyone else. I tried to show my kids both sides. Some people believe that life begins at conception, some people believe that it is only a life if it can survive outside the womb. Then I would ask them what they thought. Yes what I believe matters, but I want them to form their own opinnions on something, based on what they value, not regurgitate something they have been told.