Brock Turner was Not Convicted of Rape – Just of Trying


I want to talk about Brock Turner and his father Dan A. Turner in a new way. We are all outraged. We know that we have a problem on college campuses. We send our daughters to college with ambivalence and some amount of fear. We hope that they will not be sexually assaulted. We lecture them about drinking at parties, about going with friends, about watching out for each other. We send our sons and we hope that they will not fall into group think and victimize women by standing idly by. We pray that if they pledge a fraternity there is no abuse. We don’t have any way of knowing so we draw from our own experiences and tell ourselves, mistakenly, that it wasn’t so bad. It was.

Brock Turner was convicted of three felonies: assault with intent to rape an intoxicated woman, sexually penetrating an intoxicated person with a foreign object and sexually penetrating an unconscious person with a foreign object. Though Brock Turner is a convicted sex offender he is not a convicted rapist, he is a convicted attempted rapist. I am not prepared to say that Brock Turner is not a rapist, he very well may be a rapist but that is not the felony he was convicted of. Just the other three.

Brock Turner is not a convicted rapist. Many millions of us have read his victims horrifying, chilling and profound words. We are outraged by his mild sentence, we are awed by her strength in her pain. We feel for her family, for her boyfriend, for her colleagues and our heart aches for her sister in unimaginable ways. We know her sister feels responsible. We know her sister is not responsible. Knowing things with your head and feeling them with your heart are two different scenarios. Brock Turner broke her sister’s heart.

He will go to jail, or perhaps prison, but not for very long.

Shortly after reading the victim’s words we were treated to Dan A. Turner’s statement where presumably his words were carefully chosen. They did more than demonstrate tone deafness. They sounded like an excerpt from The Idiots Guide to Raising a Sexual Predator.

“His life will never be the one that he dreamed about and worked so hard to achieve. That is a steep price to pay for 20 minutes of action out of his 20 plus years of life.”

It is critical that we remember the horror that the victim endured. It is critical that we remember how broken she felt and how angry we are at the justice system. We need to keep in mind that almost all of America wants a judge removed because he gave a disturbingly lenient sentence to a man who perpetrated sexual violence on another human being. Violence that cannot be undone. It was more than 20 minutes.

The next time somebody talks about crimes as lesser please remember the impact on the victim. The next time you go on the Megan’s law website and see lewd and lascivious acts with a minor think of the victim’s letter. When you read “digital penetration” and think someone’s lucky they weren’t raped, think of the Stanford victim. Let’s use language well and shift the conversation from Brock Turner rapist to Brock Turner Attempted Rapist.

Emily Doe gave the world a gift with her words. Joe Biden is right, she did make the world safer. She did save lives. She also allowed us to see that sexual assault which does not include penis in vagina penetration is in an of itself a horrific crime and that we can acknowledge that as such. She showed us the rippling effect of violence when she talked about her sister:

When I see my younger sister hurting, when she is unable to keep up in school, when she is deprived of joy, when she is not sleeping, when she is crying so hard on the phone she is barely breathing, telling me over and over again she is sorry for leaving me alone that night, sorry sorry sorry, when she feels more guilt than you, then I do not forgive you. That night I had called her to try and find her, but you found me first. Your attorney’s closing statement began, “[Her sister] said she was fine and who knows her better than her sister.” You tried to use my own sister against me? Your points of attack were so weak, so low, it was almost embarrassing. You do not touch her.

Joe Biden published an open letter to Emily Doe today. It was heartfelt and compassionate and it spoke from our nation to a woman who deserved kindness and support. As an open letter it was for the country too. Unfortunately he left one line in that is both searing and cruel.

I do not know your name — but I know that a lot of people failed you that terrible January night and in the months that followed.

Anyone at that party who saw that you were incapacitated yet looked the other way and did not offer assistance.

Read the victim’s words Joe. Please, before spouting off read what you’re responding to. Read the 7,000+ words this victim wrote and where she repeated over and over again that her sister was there, that her sister felt guilty. This is why people don’t talk about campus assaults. There are so many people hurt by it. A thousand small decisions led the victim to the Sex Offender and though there was drinking and gaiety and flirting and probably even hooking up there is one sister and probably a few other people who are wracked with guilt about this event and shouldn’t be. They are victims too. They should have felt guilty that she left drunk and alone, fell over scraped her knee and puked on her beige cardigan. How was anyone to know that there was a monster in the midst?

Should we all watch out for each other? Of course. Can we in every instance? No.

There is no fault or blame to be spread around. I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again. If a crazy or drunk lady is walking down the street naked you do not have permission to put anything in her vagina, not your finger, not your penis, not your mouth. If a girl passes out at a party but was horny and kissy before passing out you still do not have permission to put anything in her, touch her breasts or any other part of her body.

We talk a lot about privilege and white privilege in particular (see the global financial breakdown of 2008 and the zero people who went to prison). We talk about treatment of elite athletes and the consequences they don’t have to pay. We know that something happened with Kobe Bryant,  we know that Mike Tyson served less than three years in youth correctional facility for a rape he committed at age 25. Ben Roethlisberger has a problem with multiple women accusing him of sexual assault and don’t forget Steubenville I could go on for ages but really we all know the story, it would be boring if it wasn’t so scary.

Because of obscene levels of privilege Brock Turner will not be in prison very long. Because of a broken culture of reverence of college athletics this judge Persky has let several other felons off easy.

Brock Turner has siblings. They will need to think about changing their names. I have no compassion for his parents. His father behaved abominably.

We need to choose our words carefully. You do not get a medal for not having taken advantage of a “promiscuous” woman. The same way that women don’t get battle for not grabbing the asses of men who are walking around without their shirts on. This Facebook update where a man talks about his heroic act of treating drunk promiscuous women just like any other was shared hundreds of thousands of times. Is that the best we can do?

Has no one read the victim’s letter? Is there anyone left who thinks that has anything to do with sex?

I want to call on everyone to pay close attention to the words we use because words are what created the situation we are in. I don’t care who you sleep with so long as it’s consensual. I don’t care if you’re gay. I don’t care if you’re straight. I don’t care if you dress up like a hedgehog and give blowjobs to dwarves. I only care that before anybody touches or enters your body that you have given them permission to do so.

And to the Stanford Victim’s Sister: Joe Biden was wrong. You failed no one.

Candy Crowley and Poppy Harlow are Sad When Rapists Get Caught Raping People


Poppy Harlow Candy Crowley

On the off chance that you’re unfamiliar with the Steubenville Rape Trial, let me bring you up to speed. According to court findings a 16 year old girl drank too much and was digitally penetrated by at least two boys who were also 16. Other allegations exist and a grand jury is quite likely. A number of boys who were present struck deals with prosecutors and will not be prosecuted. Unlike their friends they will not be registered sex offenders. They are, however, sex offenders and they are dangerous people.

The reason we all know that Ma’Lik Richmond and Trent Mays are now convicted rapists is because in addition to the sexual assault he was convicted of Mays took pictures of a naked victim and circulated them on the web. That’s actually called child pornography.

Oh, there was also this guy Michael Nordianos and his twitter feed...

The mother of the victim spoke at the sentencing and I think her words to her daughter’s rapists merit repeating:

“It did not matter what school you went to, what city you lived in, or what sport you’ve played, human compassion is not taught by a teacher, a coach or a parent.  It is a God-given gift instilled in all of us. You displayed not only a lack of this compassion but a lack of any moral code.”

She stops short of calling them evil. I don’t. When talking about her daughter the woman says:

“This does not define who my daughter is. She will perservere, grow, and move on.”

And with a mother like that I believe she will.

In the previous 250 words I have described to you two of the most detestable young men in America. They are convicted rapists who worked together to assault and humiliate a young woman. I’ve inserted almost no opinion.

On the other hand CNN (which is a network that’s typically above the fray) had two reporters on who did all they could revictimize the young girl. Candy Crowley starts her newscast by describing the boys as, “Two Star High School Football Players in Steubenville Ohio.” Well, before being remanded to prison they were football players so I suspect that is a fact.

Candy Crowley then asks Poppy Harlow to talk about the emotions in the courtroom. This is when I’m waiting for Ms. Harlow to talk about the victim’s mother and her statement or perhaps the anger of the bystanders, but no, Poppy Harlow talks about the ruined lives of Ma’Lik Richmond and Trent Mays. She also incorrectly reports their sentences as being 1 and 2 years when in fact those are minimum sentences. Juvenile court is structured differently.

At about 4 and a half minutes in Candy Crowley notes to Paul Callan (the CNN legal contributor) that a 16 year old was sobbing in court, her voice changes to an almost maternal tone while she shakes her head and seems to have a difficult time stating that the two convicted rapists are what the courts have deemed them to be. She says, “What’s the lasting effect though on two young men being found guilty in juvenile court of [pause] rape essentially.”

Forgive me Candy, did the judge say, “Rape essentially.”?

Well, for at least a year and up to five years no girls in Steubenville will be raped by these two young men. Hopefully they won’t assault anyone in detention but I think we all know that is a very real possibility. For the rest of their lives these two men will register as sex offenders and the towns they live in will be somewhat safer knowing the identities of the men who have raped before.

During sentencing Trent Mays said, “I would truly like to apologize. No pictures should have been sent around, let alone have been taken.”

Yes, we all know that if you’re a high school football player the lesson learned here is to never instagram your sexual assaults. Perhaps Candy and Poppy can teach a class on that for the next round of poor young boys who have their promising football careers cut short by a slutty girl who dares to drink to much.

Sadly there will always be rape.

I’m hopeful that one day there won’t be women like Candy and Poppy who seem to believe that rape victims ruin the lives of football stars.