Skip to content

Transactional Relationships and Social Media

friends in social media

When I worked in sales I called on insurance brokers to use the shop that I was representing. I’d make phone calls, I’d stop into offices and I’d have the occasional lunch, usually with an office manager. If they were older (I was 22-24 at the time) like 30 or more they’d treat the relationship pragmatically. I had something to sell and they had clients to please. It was easy. When the women were younger they would see me as their friend. I never really felt like their friend but here and there I’d meet them for drinks here and there. I’d probably have described someone like that as a Work Friend or perhaps an acquaintance. It’s not that I didn’t like these women, it’s that they weren’t part of my life. They only knew the work part of me and I suspected (and was correct) that when I left my job I’d leave them behind too.

Twenty years later I’m still selling things to outside vendors. Like every blogger whose blog is their day job I’m writing proposals, sending emails and having phone calls where I explain my relevance and perhaps more importantly my audience’s relevance to their product or service. I’m either defending my pageviews, explaining the value of being on a site where sidebar ads don’t compete for eyeballs or explaining why a brand isn’t a match for me but surely something else in their portfolio must be. I’ve made some friends along the way and they’re different than the vendors of my earliest career. We know each other because we’ve shared so much of ourselves on the web.

Or maybe we haven’t? Maybe we just share what we want the world to see? Facebook in June is a portfolio of vacations few can afford and I’m torn between dying slowly of envy (my Facebook friends) and being really happy for people (my real life friends).

A good number of online relationships are transactional. Please don’t assign judgement to this. A transactional relationship is neither inherently good nor inherently bad. It is simply a type of relationship. These relationships in the blogging world come about naturally with one blogger linking to another and expecting a thank you in the form of post promotion or a link back. Many bloggers join private groups and exchange comments, Stumbles, Alexa clicks or Facebook likes. Again, this isn’t a bad thing, it’s just a thing. There’s power in being part of a group and I can’t bring myself to say that being part of a group is bad or good. It’s just something that is.

It gets sticky for people who don’t reciprocate and they’ll never know that it’s gotten sticky they’ll just get frozen out. Send too many emails asking for Facebook likes and you’ll find yourself off people’s timelines. DMing for Stumbles day in and out is fine if you’re spending an equal amount of time promoting the people you’re asking (you probably aren’t). Since these Facebook friends aren’t sipping lattes in your living room or picking your kids up from school it’s unlikely that they’ll put up with too many requests.

I’m involved in many transactional relationships. My drycleaners clearly adore me and my unwillingness to iron my husband’s shirts. I pay money, they iron the shirts, I stand at the counter and they pretend to care about my day when they ask, “How are you?” I pretend that they’re listening when I say, “Fine, and you?”

Bloggers go on junkets and get to know the folks on the trip, though they genuinely may enjoy one another there are transactions occurring at every moment. Take my picture, talk about me, let’s make this fun… we’re doing for others with the expectation of something in return. I can’t even talk about how the hosts (publicists and marketers) must feel. Those are incredibly unequal relationships. One person has the ability to shower another with corporate goodies, how will they ever know if they’re liked, appreciated or respected? Does it matter?

Transactional relationships can turn into friendships. Real ones with people who enjoy and respect one another’s talents and strengths that are unrelated to work but it takes time and experience. Non transactional friendships can come from a transactional one. You might decide that you like someone enough that you don’t care about scorekeeping. It’s like crossing a million moats and in every moat there are favors you don’t need, want or ask for instead of crocodiles.



Photo credit Abdul Rahman



4 thoughts on “Transactional Relationships and Social Media”

  1. I’m reminded here about the time when I was gung-ho about mental health awareness and as a result my FB friends list increased as I “met” people that I felt a certain level of trust or mutual understanding. What I found odd was when I found myself unfriending one woman when she posted a picture of her HS senior daughter in her graduation gift – a brand-spanking new Porsche convertible. I felt bad, I was having a hard time coming to terms with the fact that it coincided with the time our family was asking for donations and relying on fee waivers for school fees, including graduation dues & robes for our kids. This was not me. I couldn’t see past that one post & photo on FB. I disliked myself for letting that mar the fact that this woman was doing so much good in mental health community. Social media is perplexing. Take Twitter. I love Twitter friends from near & far, but it does seem that folks I connected with earlier on, and even refer to as friends now, well, they all seemed to be more social when I was going through rough patch – they cheered me up, constantly checked in, offered encouraging words. But since things started improving for my family seems dialogue has tapered off, and I miss exchanges with these friends (even though I know we all have busy lives) who were there for me when actual family & friends bailed on us. I’d never think of parting ways with these people, they mean too much to me… thanks to social media. Mutual care and respect for many on twitter is the reason I log on each day. Facebook on the other hand, bugs me… mostly for lack of original thought, and I actually know or am related to those people!

  2. Thank you. p.s. a bloggers biggest mistake is when they call a PR/Publicist or brand rep a “friend.” He/She isn’t a friend. He/She is doing business with said blogger. He/She is a colleague. A Client. Possibly someone that pays the bills. Leave the personal crap out of it. WIth time, like in any other work environment, relationships may develop…but adding this ridiculous title of “my friend” to every PR/Brand rep to validate their blog is craziness.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *